Process for two-step fracturing of oil shale formations for production of shale oil

ABSTRACT

A process for in situ production of shale oil comprises fracturing the target zone  10  of an shale oil formation using a two step approach. First, an initial set of fractures  18  is developed in the formation by using high pressure gas pulses. Second, a secondary set of fractures  28  extending and further fracturing the initial set of fractures  18  is created using a modified ANFO mix  22  wherein rubber particles acting as solid fuel are blended in with ammonium nitrate and fuel oil. The solid fuel enhances the fracturing characteristics of ANFO while minimizing its crushing and compacting tendencies. Hot high pour point oil is then injected into the formation and forced into the receptor well  16  where it is pumped to the surface. By circulating oil in the formation at carefully controlled temperatures, kerogen can be decomposed at the optimum rate to maximize the amount of oil recovered and yield high quality shale oil. High pour point oil reaching cooler extremities of the fractured formation will solidify creating an impermeable perimeter barrier  34  around the target zone  10.

CROSS-REFERENCE TO RELATED APPLICATION

This application claims the benefit of U.S. Provisional Application No. 60/878,356, filed Jan. 4, 2007.

BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION

1. Field of the Invention

The invention is directed to a process for fracturing a tight subsurface formation, and more particularly to a two-step process for fracturing an oil shale formation for production of shale oil. One aspect of the invention is directed to a process for circulation of high pour point oil into the fractured formation for decomposition of in situ kerogen into and recovery of shale oil.

2. Description of the Prior Art

Production of shale oil involves at least three major technological requirements. First, a process is needed that results in the flow of fluids through a subsurface formation. Second, heating of the formation to decompose kerogen must be carefully controlled. Third, the heated portion of the formation must be permanently isolated from any adjacent aquifers. This invention is directed primarily to the first and third of these requirements, but benefits all three.

The production of shale oil results from the thermal decomposition of kerogen confined within shale formations. In situ recovery must include a process that creates pathways for the efficient flow of fluids and heat through the oil shale formation. Historically, pathways in hydrocarbon formations have been created using high explosives, hydraulic fracturing techniques, and acid treatments. Research has shown that the pressure pulse created by high explosives enlarges the well bore by crushing and compacting the surrounding rock in the formation. The enlarged well bore is left with a zone of residual compressive stress and compacted rock which can actually reduce permeability near the well bore. Extensive caving also occurs in the well bore leaving debris that may require days or even weeks to clean up. Hydraulic fracturing is highly effective but is well known to create fractures that can break out of a producing formation and into nearby aquifers.

A more recently available alternative used for fracturing a tight formation surrounding a well bore is the use of high pressure gas pulses, sometimes referred to as high energy gas fracturing. This involves activating a solid propellant, often referred to as a low explosive, to generate high-pressure gas pulses that are strong enough to create multiple fractures in the adjacent formation radiating 10 to 100 feet from the well bore, but not so strong as to pulverize and compact the rock such as is the case with high explosives. It is sometimes explained that these solid propellants do not detonate supersonically, but deflagrate at subsonic velocities. Several advantages of high-pressure gas pulse technology are that cavings are minimal, the integrity of the well bore is maintained, and clean up is nominal. The nature of the forces produced by gas pulses also has the salutary effect of creating fractures having minimal vertical propagation thereby lessening the chances of breaking into adjacent aquifers. Even so, the fracturing produced by application of high-pressure gas pulses is limited. Fewer fractures means that there are fewer pathways for fluids to flow through the formation. A corollary is that higher pressures are required to push fluids through the formation, e.g., generally from an injection well to a receptor well. Finally, the amount of oil that can be recovered, and the rate at which it can be collected, are reduced in proportion to the extent of fracturing of the formation. It is, therefore, important to increase fracturing to optimize the pathways available for flow of heating mediums and shale oil through the formation between adjacent wells.

Ammonium-nitrate fuel oil (ANFO) is one of a class of high explosive compositions which includes an oxidizing agent and a liquid hydrocarbon component. Ammonium-nitrate is by far the preferred oxidizing agent and #2 fuel oil is usually the liquid hydrocarbon of choice. ANFO may be modified to reduce the shock energy and increase the heave energy of the explosion. ANFO so modified, commonly known as a low shock energy explosive, has been used in quarrying operations in rock blasting situations, but has never been used for fracturing oil shale formations.

It is critically important to avoid contamination of aquifers located in proximity to the targeted portion of the formation. Heating fluids injected into the formation, while necessary and effective for extracting shale oil deposits, may contaminate aquifers. Moreover, the process of extracting shale oil can release contaminants which should be prevented from leaching into adjacent aquifers where they may contaminate water used for drinking and agriculture. The vertical fracturing which results from hydraulic fracturing techniques can intersect natural vertical fractures in the formation creating pathways to aquifers usually located in horizontal strata above or below a target formation.

BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE ILLUSTRATIONS

FIG. 1A is a perspective view of the target zone of a subsurface formation in which two wells have been drilled and an initial set of fractures has been created.

FIG. 1B is a sectional elevational of a portion of the formation shown in FIG. 1A taken along line 1A showing representative fractures in the formation.

FIG. 2 is a sectional plan view of a horizontal section of the target zone depicted in FIG. 1.

FIG. 3 is a perspective view similar to that of FIG. 1A wherein a mixture of modified ANFO has been injected into the well bores and several C-4 charges positioned according to the invention.

FIG. 4A is a perspective view similar to that of FIG. 3 showing a secondary set of fractures created by detonation of the modified ANFO mix according to the invention.

FIG. 4B is a detail sectional elevational view of a portion of FIG. 4A showing the initial and secondary set of fractures in the formation and sand particles in the fractures.

FIG. 5 is a plan view of a horizontal section of the target zone depicted in FIG. 4A showing the initial and secondary sets of fractures.

FIG. 6 is a sectional plan view showing solidification of high pour point oil, having been injected into the target zone according to the invention, in a perimeter region surrounding and encasing the target zone.

FIG. 7 is a sectional elevational view of an expanded target zone showing the original injector and receptor wells and a new well, wherein pressurized gas is being injected into the original injector well.

DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE ILLUSTRATED EMBODIMENTS

A process for two-step fracturing of an oil shale formation for production of oil shale according to the invention comprises a series of steps each of which is discussed in detail below in relation to the attached drawings.

With reference to FIG. 1, the initial step is to drill sets of open hole completion wells into the target zone 10 of an identified oil shale formation below an overburden 12 to targeted depths, the wells including at least one injection well 14 and one or more receptor wells 16. Identification of the location of an oil shale formation and focus therein on a target zone are matters well understood by those of skill in the art. The wells 14, 16 are spaced to ensure that the subsequent fracturing process results in a satisfactory interconnection between them in the target formation.

Next an initial set of fractures 18 is created by generating high pressure gas pulses in both the injection and receptor wells 14, 16. Individual charges 20 of solid propellant are lowered into the wells and positioned in the target zone 10. Charges 20 are characteristically formed into long cylindrical shapes and are customarily approximately ten feet long. Several charges 20 may be positioned one on top of the other according to the specified depth of the formation to be fractured. Once the charge or charges are in place, they are detonated one-by-one at decreasing depths to create a network of interconnected fractures 18 in the target formation 10 in a pattern radiating from the well bores 14, 16 for up to twenty to twenty-five feet. A common characteristic of fractures created by generation of high pressure gas pulses in this manner is that the fractures have a vertical dimension roughly equivalent to the height, or long dimension, of the charge 20, while having a very much narrower width of perhaps one-eighth of an inch. See, for example, FIG. 1B. Thus, if a single ten foot long charge 20 is detonated, the resulting fractures may have an approximate height of ten feet, an approximate width of one-eighth of an inch, and radiate out from the well bore for perhaps twenty to twenty-five fee. Consequently, there is a considerable amount of vertical interconnection between individual fractures throughout the initial set of fractures 18 although this is not particularly shown in the illustrations. Ideally, the fractures 18 extending from adjacent wells overlap and interconnect to establish communication pathways for the flow of fluids and gases. If a string of several charges 20 is detonated, the fractures created by each charge will tend to link up vertically.

With reference to FIGS. 3A and 3B, following creation of the initial set of fractures 18, a secondary set of fractures is developed. To this end a modified ANFO explosive composition is prepared by adding a particulate solid fuel to the underlying mix. Solid fuel increases the rock splitting capabilities of the mix by slowing the release of energy upon detonation; thus reducing the shock energy and increasing the heave energy of the explosion similar to the explosive signature of high pressure gas pulses. Rubber particles are the preferred choice of solid fuel. Alternatives include, however, gilsonite, unexpanded polystyrene in solid form, acrylonitrile-butadiene-styrene (ABS), waxed wood meal, rosin, and certain non-absorbent carbonaceous materials. The rubber may be selected from natural rubbers, synthetic rubbers, or combinations thereof.

Post-detonation detection devices, such as geophones, are first used to determine the location of the initial set of fractures 18. C-4 explosive charges 24 are then positioned in the well bores adjacent the target zone 10 for detonating the modified ANFO 22. In one aspect of the invention, advantage is taken of the C-4 charges 24 by positioning them as near as possible to bedding planes 25 marking transition points between stratigraphic layers in the formation. By placing the charges 24 adjacent these inherently weak points in the formation, additional fracturing should result upon detonation and, conversely, any tendency to pulverize the surrounding formation should be reduced. The modified ANFO solution 22, blended in the correct proportions to be explosive, is then injected into both injector and receptor wells 14, 16. Therefrom, as seen in FIG. 3, it flows into the initial set of fractures 18. Finally, the wells 14, 16 are tamped, at 26, and the charges 24 detonated to, in turn, activate the modified ANFO 22. The liquid ANFO mix 22, having penetrated into the initial set of fractures 18, will upon detonation create a relatively dense set of secondary fractures 28 some portion of which extend generally perpendicularly from the initial set of fractures 18, some of which may extend the reach of the initial fractures, and some of which will extend directly from the well bore wall. See FIGS. 4A, 4B, and 5. The secondary set of fractures 28 tends further to break and “rubblize” the formation because of the generally vertical nature of the profile of the initial set of fractures 18, creating thereby an expanded network of interconnections between the injector and receptor wells 14, 16. Use of the modified ANFO mix in concert with high pressure gas pulses improves fracturing capabilities thereby facilitating use of such methods at greater depths in the formation. Most evidently, infusing modified ANFO in the formation, initially fractured by application of high pressure gas pulse technology, increases the volume of the explosive which can be used, resulting in a significant increase in the volume of the formation that is fractured. Moreover, more uniform fracturing results and fewer oil shale fines are created.

In one embodiment of the invention sand may be added to the modified ANFO mixture for two purposes. First, it is thought that sand acts as a heat sink during the explosion, thus helping to shift some of the shock energy of the explosion to heave energy. Second, sand particles 30 may help prop open the network of fractures created according to the invention as shown in FIG. 4B.

If water is present in the target zone, it may be necessary to use water-thickening or water-resistant ANFO mixtures. For example, if natural fractures are encountered in the formation which may lead to an aquifer, water-thickening agents may be added to the ANFO mix that will form an impermeable paste impeding leakage of the explosive out of the target zone. Alternatively, an ANFO mixture having water-resistant properties may be used if water is present in the target formation but there is no risk of contaminating adjacent aquifers.

It will be readily understood by those of skill in the art that the above-described method of creating initial and secondary fracturing need not be restricted to oil shale formations and can be applied to any tight formation. It should also be understood that the modified ANFO mixture can be used in just one well to increase the flow of surrounding trapped gas or oil or that it can be used cooperatively in adjacent wells as described above.

According to one aspect of the invention, the modified ANFO composition is detonated in open hole wells. In such cases, the wells may have to be redrilled and fitted with an insulated casing. To verify that the sets of fractures extending from each well have been connected with each other, hot gases are forced into the injector well and collected in the receptor well. Measurement of the flow rate and the pressure required to push the gases through the fractures and out the receptor well will provide an indication of the degree of interconnection. If the fractures are not adequately interconnected it may be appropriate to use the modified ANFO explosive mix again to create additional fracturing extending from one or both wells. Sufficient interconnection is important to avoid creating hydraulically induced fractures in subsequent phases of the recovery operation. The use of hot gases for flow verification will also preheat the fractures to facilitate the next phase in which the formation is injected with high pour point.

The oil shale is then heated by injecting hot oil through the fractures from the injector well 14 to the receptor well 16 in the direction of the arrows shown in FIG. 4A. The hot oil used for this step of the process will be waxy with a pour point of 90° F.+. The use of high pour point oil ensures that the oil will solidify as it reaches the cooler extremities 32 of the network of fractures most remote from the well bores. Thus, advantageously, the solidified high pour point oil will create an impermeable perimeter barrier 34 as shown in FIG. 6. This effectively blocks any contaminants generated during the heating process from migrating away from the target formation and prevents passage of water through the developed formation.

Exposing kerogen to excessive heat can result in coking of this organic material. Therefore, the temperature and the rate of heating of the hot oil being injected in the formation must be carefully controlled to avoid overexposing the kerogen to excessive temperatures and to ensure a proper rate of decomposition. Any coking of the shale oil results in lower recovery efficiencies and also degrades the quality of the produced oil. Avoiding exposure of the kerogen to excessive heating rates and temperatures ensures maximum recovery of the shale oil as well as optimum quality of oil produced by the process. An advantage of the additional rubblizing of the formation according to the process of the invention, which creates additional pathways for fluid flow between injector and receptor wells, is that decomposed shale oil need spend less time flowing through the formation exposed to the heat of the circulating high pour point oil. This reduces the potential for coking of the kerogen and increases the quality of the shale oil recovered from the formation. The pressure needed to force oil and other mediums through the formation is also reduced in proportion to the additional pathways created by the invention.

The main surface facilities in support of the invention consist of pressure vessels for pressurizing the hot oil to be injected into the formation and for collecting the hot oil flowing from the formation. A back pressure control valve on the receptor well and careful monitoring of the outlet temperature will be used to restrict flow of the circulating hot oil to force it through all of the connected fractures in the target zone and avoid bypassing. A gas fired furnace will be used to heat the oil prior to injection. Compressed inert gas within the injection vessel will be used initially to provide the needed pressure for forcing the hot oil into the fractured shale. A down hole pump may be needed in the receptor well for forcing the recovered oil back to the surface. Pressure cycling of the injection and receptor vessels will be needed to force the collected hot oil back through the furnace and into the injection vessel. A batch process will be used to move the oil in this manner. There will be two injection vessels and two receptor vessels so the flow of oil from injector to receptor can be continuous. The use of pressure instead of pumping to recycle the oil precludes the problems that would be created with pumping a hot fluid containing some amount of fines. The receptor vessels will also act as a distillation column to take advantage of the heat input for distillation of those produced shale oil streams that have lower boiling points.

Gases will be produced along with the shale oil as the formation reaches the decomposition temperature of the kerogen. This residual gas will then be used as fuel for the hot oil furnace and also will be compressed to force the hot oil from the injector well. Net produced gas will be pipelined to gas processing facilities for commercial sale.

The quality and volume of the flowing hot oil will change as the shale oil is produced. Full recovery will be evident as the net production of shale oil eventually diminishes. As the completion of recovery is approached the temperature of the hot circulating oil will be rapidly increased from approximately 650-700° F. to approximately 800-900° F. This will produce a poorer quality shale oil with a higher pour point. Residual amounts of this high pour point oil will remain in the formation after recovery efforts. This material will eventually solidify and will provide an additional barrier against water flowing into the impacted zone. This further precludes the possibility of contaminants being carried into other substrata and reaching underlying aquifers. Injection of the hot oil will be terminated when maximum recovery has been determined. At this point recovery of oil remaining in the formation will be initiated.

When oil circulation has been terminated, some recoverable oil will remain in the fractured formation. A CO₂ miscible flood process will be used to recover the remaining oil in the target zone. This process will be relatively efficient in terms of percent recovery as the oil is already heated to the decomposition temperature of the kerogen. The high pour point oil will remain solidified in the extremities of the target zone and continue to act as an impermeable membrane around the target zone providing an impenetrable barrier to the CO₂.

CO₂ will continue to be forced into the formation at the optimum pressure to maximize storage of CO₂. The solidification of the high pour point oil around and within the target zone will prevent any acids formed by interaction of the CO₂ with water from being leached out of the formation where they might contaminate any aquifers lower in the substrata.

According to a further aspect of the invention, after the formation has been exhausted between the injection and receptor wells, the fracturing-heating process may be applied to adjacent wells. With reference to FIG. 7, as the original target zone 40 adjacent the injection and receptor wells 14, 16 nears complete recovery, another zone 42 adjacent the original zone 40 may be developed by drilling a new well 44 and fracturing the formation surrounding it. The new well 44 will most likely be located in line with the first two wells 14, 16, in order to maximize the size of the new zone 42. It will be clear, however, that the new well 44 may be located anywhere adjacent one or the other of the first two wells 14, 16, but preferably where is it best calculated to maximize recovery from the new zone 42.

Recovery from the new well 44 is preceded by injection of pressurized gas G into one of the first two wells, e.g., as illustrated in FIG. 7, into the original injector well 14. Gas injection into the first injector well 14 will set up an ambient pressure P in the network of fractures surrounding well 14 at least as great as the pressure required to force oil through the new zone 42 in order to preclude backflow beyond pressure front 36 of hot oil into the network of fractures surrounding well 14. Once the required gas pressure P has been established, injection of hot high pour point oil H into one of the other wells can be initiated. In the illustrated embodiment shown in FIG. 7, the hot oil H is injected in the “old” receptor well 16, thereby turning it into a “new” injector well, and the oil is circulated through the new formation in the direction of the arrows. An alternative, however, would be to inject the hot high pour point oil H into the new well 44 making it an injection well and retaining the “old” receptor well 16 to serve the same purpose with respect to the new injector well 44. Additional wells can be added in the same manner. A down hole ambient pressure will be maintained in exhausted wells using injected gas G to isolate new formation zones as they are developed.

There have thus been described certain preferred embodiments of a process for two-step fracturing of oil shale formations for production of shale oil. While preferred embodiments have been described and disclosed, it will be recognized by those with skill in the art that modifications are within the true spirit and scope of the invention. The appended claims are intended to cover all such modifications. 

1. A process for two-step fracturing of a subsurface formation comprising: drilling at least one well into a target zone of the formation, said at least one well having a well bore, generating one or more high pressure gas pulses in said well bore to create an initial set of fractures in said target zone, injecting into said initial set of fractures an explosive composition including an oxidizing agent, a liquid hydrocarbon component, and a solid fuel material in particulate form, said explosive composition for producing a low shock energy explosion, and detonating said explosive composition to create a secondary set of fractures, a portion of said secondary set of fractures extending from said initial set of fractures.
 2. The process for two-step fracturing of a subsurface formation of claim 1 wherein: said target zone contains oil shale.
 3. The process for two-step fracturing of a subsurface formation of claim 1 wherein: said one or more high pressure gas pulses are generated by deflagrating a solid propellant.
 4. The process for two-step fracturing of a subsurface formation of claim 1 wherein: said oxidizing agent comprises ammonium-nitrate.
 5. The process for two-step fracturing of a subsurface formation of claim 1 wherein: said liquid hydrocarbon component comprises fuel oil.
 6. The process for two-step fracturing of a subsurface formation of claim 1 wherein: said solid fuel material in said explosive composition comprises rubber particles.
 7. The process for two-step fracturing of a subsurface formation of claim 1 wherein: said explosive composition includes sand.
 8. The process for two-step fracturing of a subsurface formation of claim 1 wherein: said at least one well comprises a plurality of wells, said plurality of wells having at least one injector well and at least one receptor well, and said initial and secondary sets of fractures are created in said target zone adjacent each of said injector and receptor wells.
 9. The process for two-step fracturing of a subsurface formation of claim 8 further comprising: injecting hot gases into said initial and secondary sets of fractures at said injector well, and collecting said hot gases flowing through said initial and secondary sets of fractures at said receptor well to verify interconnection of said injector and receptor wells through said initial and secondary set of fractures.
 10. The process for two-step fracturing of a subsurface formation of claim 9 further comprising: measuring the flow rate of said hot gases and the pressure required to push said gases through said initial and secondary sets of fractures between said injector well and said receptor well.
 11. The process for two-step fracturing of a subsurface formation of claim 8 further comprising: injecting hot gases into said initial and secondary sets of fractures at said injector well to preheat said target zone, and collecting said hot gases from said receptor well.
 12. The process for two-step fracturing of a subsurface formation of claim 8 further comprising: injecting high pour point oil into said initial and secondary sets of fractures adjacent said injector well to heat said target zone to decompose kerogen deposits in said formation into recoverable shale oil, said high pour point oil having a pour point of at least approximately 90° F., circulating said high pour point oil between said injector well and said receptor well, and recovering entrained shale oil from said receptor well.
 13. The process for two-step fracturing of a subsurface formation of claim 12 wherein: said high pour point oil solidifies in outlying extensions of said initial and secondary sets of fractures forming a contamination barrier around said target zone.
 14. The process for two-step fracturing of a subsurface formation of claim 12 further comprising: restricting flow of oil out of said receptor well to maximize the portion of said initial and secondary sets of fractures through which said oil flows between said injector and receptor wells.
 15. The process for two-step fracturing of a subsurface formation of claim 12 further comprising: injecting hot CO₂ into said target zone at said injector well, and recovering residual oil from said target zone from said receptor well.
 16. The process for two-step fracturing of a subsurface formation of claim 12 further comprising: injecting gas into a third well to create an ambient pressure in said initial and secondary sets of fractures in communication with said third well, said ambient pressure at least as great as an oil pressure created by said injecting of high pour point oil into said initial and secondary sets of fractures adjacent said injector well.
 17. The process for two-step fracturing of a subsurface formation of claim 16 wherein: said gas comprises CO₂.
 18. The process for two-step fracturing of a subsurface formation of claim 12 further comprising: rapidly raising the temperature of said circulating high pour point oil sufficiently to decompose shale oil in the formation into high pour point oil.
 19. The process for two-step fracturing of a subsurface formation of claim 1 further comprising: placing one or more charges of C-4 explosive in said well bore for detonating said explosive composition.
 20. The process for two-step fracturing of a subsurface formation of claim 19 wherein: at least one of said one or more C-4 charges is positioned in planar alignment with a bedding plane in the formation.
 21. The process for two-step fracturing of a subsurface formation of claim 1 further comprising: filling said well bore and said initial set of fractures with a volume of water, measuring said volume of water to determine the amount of said explosive composition needed for said injection into said initial set of fractures, and removing said volume of water from said well bore and said initial set of fractures.
 22. A process for two-step fracturing of an oil shale formation for production of shale oil comprising: drilling at least one well into a target zone of the oil shale formation, said at least one well having a well bore, generating one or more high pressure gas pulses in said well bore to create an initial set of fractures in said target zone, injecting into said initial set of fractures an ammonium-nitrate and fuel oil explosive composition, said explosive composition modified to include rubber particles for producing a low shock energy explosion, and detonating said explosive composition to create a secondary set of fractures extending from said initial set of fractures.
 23. A process for two-step fracturing of an oil shale formation for production of shale oil comprising: drilling a plurality of wells into a target zone of the oil shale formation, said plurality of wells having at least one injector well and at least one receptor well, each of said wells having a well bore, generating one or more high pressure gas pulses in said well bores to create an initial set of fractures in said target zone, injecting into said initial set of fractures an ammonium-nitrate and fuel oil explosive composition, said explosive composition modified to include rubber particles for producing a low shock energy explosion, detonating said explosive composition to create a secondary set of fractures extending from said initial set of fractures, injecting high pour point oil into said initial and secondary sets of fractures adjacent said injector well to heat said target zone to decompose kerogen deposits in said formation into recoverable shale oil, said high pour point oil having a pour point of at least approximately 90° F., circulating said high pour point oil between said injection well and said receptor well, and recovering and said shale oil entrained with said high pour point oil from said receptor well.
 24. A process for production of shale oil comprising: drilling a plurality of wells into a target zone of the oil shale formation, said plurality of wells having at least one injector well and at least one receptor well, creating a set of fractures in said target zone, injecting high pour point oil into said set of fractures adjacent said injector well to heat said target zone to decompose kerogen deposits in said formation into recoverable shale oil, said high pour point oil having a pour point of at least approximately 90° F., circulating said high pour point oil between said injection well and said receptor well, and recovering shale oil entrained with said high pour point oil from said receptor well.
 25. A process for production of shale oil of claim 24 wherein: forming a contamination barrier around said target zone from said high pour point oil that solidifies in outlying extensions of said set of fractures.
 26. A process for production of shale oil of claim 24 wherein: creating a set of fractures in said target zone includes generating one or more high pressure gas pulses in said well bore to create an initial set of fractures in said target zone, injecting into said initial set of fractures an explosive composition including an oxidizing agent, a liquid hydrocarbon component, and a solid fuel material in particulate form, said explosive composition for producing a low shock energy explosion, and detonating said explosive composition to create a secondary set of fractures, a portion of said secondary set of fractures extending from said initial set of fractures. 